
How to Manage Payment Disputes in Squarespace Payments
Payment disputes occur when customers challenge transactions with their bank. Here's how to handle them through Squarespace Payments:
Common Reasons for Disputes:
- Fraudulent charges
- Missing refunds
- Duplicate transactions
- Non-delivery of products/services
- Quality issues
- Subscription cancellation issues
- Unrecognized payments
Dispute Process:
- A $20 fee and disputed amount are deducted from your payout balance
- If insufficient funds exist, charges go to your linked bank account
- You'll receive email notifications and dashboard alerts
- Response deadlines range from 20-45 days
- Reminder emails sent 5 days and 2 days before deadline
Dispute Statuses:
- Dispute open
- Response submitted
- Deadline missed
- Dispute approved
- Dispute rejected
Handling Disputes:
- Contact the customer directly for resolution
- Accept or challenge through Payments dashboard
- Note: Cannot issue refunds once dispute opens
Accepting Disputes:
- Open Finance dashboard
- Click "View details" next to dispute
- Select "Accept dispute"
- Payment status changes to "lost dispute"
Challenging Disputes: Submit evidence including:
- Store refund policy/terms
- Refund denial reason
- Processing data (tracking numbers, delivery confirmation)
- Customer communications
- Other relevant documentation
To Submit Evidence:
- Access Finance dashboard > Orders
- Select disputed payment
- Click "Start response to dispute"
- Describe evidence
- Save draft or submit
Resolution:
- Bank reviews evidence within 60-75 days
- If successful, transaction amount returns to your account
- Refund fee may or may not be returned
- Non-response results in automatic loss and finalized refund
Note: American Express and Discover may initiate an inquiry phase before dispute, without immediate fee deduction.
Related Articles

How to Manage Squarespace Payments Settings and Account Details
